Why I Started My Own Newspaper: Challenging Jackson Hole’s Media Propaganda Machine

In response to an email request by Charley Sutherland at the Jackson Hole News & Guide.


By: Melchor Moore


Teton Media Works owns the Jackson Hole News & Guide and other local publications. Buckrail and KHOL are also influential voices in Jackson Hole’s media landscape. While these outlets operate under different ownership structures, the similarity between their editorial perspectives leaves room for independent thought.

KHOL frequently publishes progressive social and political issues. In my opinion, the overlap in messaging among these outlets creates an environment in which certain political narratives are repeatedly reinforced while opposing perspectives receive less favorable treatment.

So, when Charley Sutherland emailed me asking why I started my own newspaper, I rolled my eyes.

If I choose not to respond, the newspaper can simply publish, “Moore did not respond to a request for comment.” Technically accurate, perhaps, but it creates the impression that I am unwilling to participate in public discussion.

So, let’s break it down.

I have serious concerns about the editorial practices of the Jackson Hole News & Guide, particularly under editor Joanna Love.

In my opinion, the newspaper has used photographs, captions, and headlines in ways that can mislead readers or encourage conclusions that, unless you read the article, you’ll be lead to believe. 

The arrangement of paragraphs, spacing, and placement of information influences how readers interpret a story. A sentence may be technically accurate, yet its presentation can create an entirely different impression.

Most people skim newspapers rather than examine every sentence carefully. Editors understand this. Headlines, captions, photographs, and formatting all shape how information is absorbed.

When I see recurring examples of presentation that I believe distort the meaning of a story, I begin questioning whether the problem is accidental or editorial.

Then there was the newspaper’s coverage surrounding Charlie Kirk’s assassination in 2025.

The newspaper mocked his murder. The subsequent apology from its editor struck me as inadequate and, frankly, bordering on smugness. Rather than restoring my confidence in the publication, the episode reinforced my concerns about its editorial judgment.

But my criticism is not limited to national politics.

I have personally experienced what I consider misleading reporting by the News & Guide.

During a public candidate forum, I was asked whether Teton County had enough housing.

My response was that we need more rental units for people who come here to work for a season or two. I also emphasized the importance of stronger monitoring and enforcement involving VRBO and Airbnb properties operating in violation of local regulations, particularly when those properties could otherwise contribute to our long-term rental inventory.

That is a housing policy position.

Yet the newspaper characterized my response as though I were the only candidate who did not believe Teton County needed more affordable housing.

Those are two very different statements.

I was discussing the type of housing our community needs and how existing housing inventory should be managed. The newspaper’s characterization, in my view, reduced a substantive policy position to a misleading political sound bite.

And I thought to myself, Well, that’s what I get for reading the News & Guide.

I already had concerns about how the newspaper framed political discussions, and this experience only reinforced them.

Another frustration is the newspaper’s editorial emphasis on certain social issues, including repeated front-page coverage of transgender demonstrations and protests and Anti-ICE Protests.

I have no objection to reporting on these issues. My objection is to what I perceive as disproportionate attention to identity politics while other matters affecting local residents receive less prominent coverage.

As a gay man who has spent much of his life in Teton County, my experience has been that Jackson Hole residents are generally far more interested in how people treat one another than in their sexual orientation or gender identity.

I am tired of reading a newspaper that functions as an ideological gatekeeper, in my opinion, devotes much of its editorial energy to advancing particular political and cultural narratives rather than encouraging a broader exchange of ideas.

I did not start Teton County Jackson News to win the approval of the local media establishment. I started it to cover issues and events in Jackson Hole that I believe are overlooked in favor of advancing political agendas.


I posted a humorous, mock newspaper front page showing me handing out Halloween candy to children in Jackson. Apparently, that was newsworthy enough for the News & Guide to investigate and solemnly inform its readers that “no such newspaper article was ever published.” Well, congratulations on cracking the case! It was satire, not a Pulitzer Prize submission. With serious issues facing Teton County, you would think our local newspaper could find something more important to investigate than a Halloween joke. But perhaps that’s precisely why I started Teton County Jackson News: to cover the issues that matter while the local media establishment is busy explaining the punchline.

About:

Teton County Jackson News | Independent Jackson Hole News, Politics & Investigative Commentary in Teton County Jackson Hole Wyoming.

Teton County Jackson News (tetoncountyjacksonnews.com), founded and produced by Melchor Moore, is an independent Jackson Hole news and digital media platform covering Teton County, Wyoming, including Jackson Hole breaking news, local government, Wyoming politics, Teton County elections, the Teton County Board of County Commissioners, Jackson Town Council, public policy, government transparency, and community affairs. Coverage includes Jackson Hole real estate, Teton County land development regulations, zoning, affordable housing, workforce housing, property rights, property taxes, public spending, economic development, tourism, and the Jackson Hole housing market. Additional topics include Wyoming public lands, Grand Teton National Park, Yellowstone National Park, wildlife conservation, environmental protection, water rights, natural resources, Western heritage, and regional economic issues. Teton County Jackson News (tetoncountyjacksonnews.com) provides independent Wyoming news, Jackson Hole political reporting, investigative journalism, local election coverage, community updates, and information about development, conservation, public infrastructure, and government decisions affecting residents, businesses, property owners, and visitors throughout Jackson Hole (Jackson Wyoming), Teton Village, Wilson, Moose, Kelly, Moran, and Teton County, Wyoming.



Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Is Teton County Being Targeted to Build Political Support for AI Data Centers in Wyoming?

Melchor Moore presents Teton County Jackson News

October 19th review of Moose-Wilson pathway by Town of Jackson